The lifeguard chair is empty by mid-September, and by October, the long stretch of sand and sea sits quietly - save for an enthusiastic dog or two.
Taped inside the ice cream shop window, a hand-lettered sign reads, “See you in May!” The parking lot, once full of vintage Broncos with college stickers and rental cars, now offers me a spot right up front at the dune-lined entrance.
That's when I go.
And I've come to realize this is not just a beach habit. I like things best when everyone else has left.
I think of myself as an off-season girl.
It's a type, the way some people are morning people or cat people, and you can spot us if you know what to look for.
We grab a bite at the hot new restaurant…but at five o'clock, when the waiter has time to chat.
We travel on Tuesdays and come home on Sunday mornings, sacrificing an extra vacation day for an uncrowded airport.
We go to the movies midweek - even to matinees, when there are plenty of empty seats.
It's as though we've learned where the quiet is hiding, and we go there.
It's not that I don't like people - I just like fewer of them.
But I wasn't always an off-season girl. For years, I was happily - exuberantly - on-season.
I waited in long lines to get into concerts, sometimes for so long I could have learned the guitar solos myself. I booked vacations during the same busy weeks as half the country and loved running into friends in crowded, faraway places. I called restaurants weeks in advance to secure a table at seven o'clock on a Saturday night, and I thrived on the buzz of a full room.
Part of what changed was my calendar.
For years, school schedules and work kept me on the same clock as everyone else. But now that my time is more my own, I can go to the beach on a Tuesday in October without asking permission or faking a very convincing cough. I know that's a luxury many people don't have.
But somewhere along the way, I stopped chasing the height of things and started appreciating what comes after. And it fits me better than I ever expected.
What I've gained is hard to measure, but easy to feel.
The greatest gifts of the off-season are time and attention. And it turns out, each one feeds the other.
When I'm not negotiating crowds, I have room to notice things I might otherwise miss - the late-afternoon light on the water, the history behind a vintage piece in a quiet shop, the barista who remembers my order because I'm one of only five customers.
Conversations linger. Stories unfold. Small encounters become memorable ones.
The height of the season moves fast, and it has to. The off-season moves at the speed of a good conversation.
I feel the same way about my own town.
I love it all year, but especially when half the neighborhood is off somewhere else and the rest of us have the place to ourselves. The roads are easy, the parking spots outnumber the cars, and a quick trip to the market turns into a handful of conversations and a generously shared recipe for chicken curry.
It feels less like a town I live in and more like one I share with the people who stay.
One fall afternoon on Nantucket, I set out on a long walk in perfect sweater weather and kept going until I reached Brant Point Lighthouse.
In the summer, visitors jostle for the same photograph. That afternoon, there was just one couple, celebrating their fortieth anniversary, with the whole place to themselves.
Well, almost.
I offered to take their picture, and they insisted on taking mine.
Somewhere, there's a photograph of two happy people and a lighthouse. And I have one of myself, grinning in a sweater, with no one waiting for a turn.
That's the off-season in a single afternoon.
Of course, there are drawbacks to living a few steps behind the crowd.
By the time I buy the jacket everyone was wearing last fall, it's on the clearance rack. I proudly put it on just as the rest of the world has moved on. I see movies after everyone has stopped talking about them, and occasionally discover a wonderful restaurant just in time for it to close.
And yes, I miss things. Fireworks on the Fourth, a few sold-out concerts, and the kind of noisy, happy night that only happens when everyone shows up at once and stays late.
There is real joy in being where everyone is, cheering for the same thing at the same moment.
On-season people keep the world lively. They fill the stadiums, the boardwalks, and the dance floors.
Off-season girls just tend to arrive once the music has softened.
So let the on-season folks have July.
Let them have the boardwalk, the fireworks, and the beach umbrellas lined up like a rainbow from the dunes to the waterline. Let them have the man who brings a full-size grill to a patch of sand the size of a bath towel (somebody has to, and he's clearly living his dream. Let them have the airport the day before Thanksgiving and the bumper-to-bumper drive to see the leaves at their glorious peak.
I'll be cheering them on from home, having eaten dinner at five and changed into pajamas by eight. Because I have come to love a life that doesn't always require me to be in the middle of everything.
Perhaps that's what the off-season has taught me. For years, I thought the best part of anything was when it was at its fullest. Now I'm beginning to think some of the best things reveal themselves only after the crowd has gone.
And so, in October, the beach is mine again.
I pull into my spot right up front at the dune-lined entrance, walk past the empty lifeguard chair, and head toward the water.
Somewhere down the shore, a happy, energetic dog is having the best day of his life. He doesn't seem to mind that he missed summer.
Neither do I.
The crowds will come back next year, right on schedule. And when they leave, this off-season girl will be there, right on mine.
But shh. Don't tell anyone.